Britain has no written Constitution, so a simple Parliamentary majority is enough to pass any Law and given that they have First Past The Post (same as the US), a party can get a simple Parliamentary majority with a ridiculously low number of votes.
For example, the current British government (the one overtly indulging in the authoritarianism this video illustrates, as well as passing seriously ridiculous laws like the one that made Choke-sex a Crime in Britain) has such a simple Parliamentary majority with just 34% of votes cast (which given the turnout of last elections is the support of less than 25% of the voters) and that’s without taking into account “tactical voting” - something that does NOT exist under PV - which brings in a lot of votes from those who do not support them but rather detest the other party in the local power duopoly.
In some ways the UK is actually worse than the US, it’s just that they’re far more polite and posh about the whole thing rather than the in-your-face loud politics and open violence in the US, and the reason being (IMHO) because the upper-middle and upper class in Britain have this whole culture of posh with stereotypes like The English Gentleman (which isn’t at all about being honorable, fair or any such character qualities, rather it’s entirely about “projecting the right impression” even when putting others down).
a simple Parliamentary majority is enough to pass any Law and given that they have First Past The Post (same as the US), a party can get a simple Parliamentary majority with a ridiculously low number of votes.
In the House of Commons, law still needs to make its way through the House of Lords as well which is a non elected chamber with a mixture of hereditary peers, bishops, former politicians, field experts, etc.
It’s not a good system, I oppose it, but it’s not quite as simple and unstable a system as you portray.
Your final paragraph is just nonsense. The upper crust have no qualms crushing the hoi polloi when they desire.
Their lack of a codified freedom of speech does not mean they have a practical reduction of freedom of speech compared to the USA. If you get shot by a cop you will never say anything at all, if they run you over you will spend a lot of time in hospital recovering and have massive medical debt, and if you are simply arrested while speaking and never get to actually raise the case that they breached your first amendment rights then you don’t really have them.
A right without enforcement is not a right, it is a privilege you are granted at the will of the government. If there was a criminal prosecution waiting for government actors who breach the rights of citizens then you could consider it a right somewhat, but ultimately nobody really has that right now, not anyone in the west, not anybody on the planet.
ICE jails a fraction of what the US penal system does. If you hate ICE racism then how must people feel about the US justice system that is far far worse.
ICE is what is happening right now, you are right.
I was just pointing out this same thing (racial profiling) has always been a part of US policing. The US has destroyed millions of minority and impoverished families with the War on Drugs as just one example.
UK does a lot of things better than the US, but their lack of a free speech law is insane.
Seriously, I’m always shocked to see stuff like this.
Makes me feel ever so slightly better to be an American in this horrible time.
Britain has no written Constitution, so a simple Parliamentary majority is enough to pass any Law and given that they have First Past The Post (same as the US), a party can get a simple Parliamentary majority with a ridiculously low number of votes.
For example, the current British government (the one overtly indulging in the authoritarianism this video illustrates, as well as passing seriously ridiculous laws like the one that made Choke-sex a Crime in Britain) has such a simple Parliamentary majority with just 34% of votes cast (which given the turnout of last elections is the support of less than 25% of the voters) and that’s without taking into account “tactical voting” - something that does NOT exist under PV - which brings in a lot of votes from those who do not support them but rather detest the other party in the local power duopoly.
In some ways the UK is actually worse than the US, it’s just that they’re far more polite and posh about the whole thing rather than the in-your-face loud politics and open violence in the US, and the reason being (IMHO) because the upper-middle and upper class in Britain have this whole culture of posh with stereotypes like The English Gentleman (which isn’t at all about being honorable, fair or any such character qualities, rather it’s entirely about “projecting the right impression” even when putting others down).
In the House of Commons, law still needs to make its way through the House of Lords as well which is a non elected chamber with a mixture of hereditary peers, bishops, former politicians, field experts, etc.
It’s not a good system, I oppose it, but it’s not quite as simple and unstable a system as you portray.
Your final paragraph is just nonsense. The upper crust have no qualms crushing the hoi polloi when they desire.
For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Orgreave
Their lack of a codified freedom of speech does not mean they have a practical reduction of freedom of speech compared to the USA. If you get shot by a cop you will never say anything at all, if they run you over you will spend a lot of time in hospital recovering and have massive medical debt, and if you are simply arrested while speaking and never get to actually raise the case that they breached your first amendment rights then you don’t really have them.
A right without enforcement is not a right, it is a privilege you are granted at the will of the government. If there was a criminal prosecution waiting for government actors who breach the rights of citizens then you could consider it a right somewhat, but ultimately nobody really has that right now, not anyone in the west, not anybody on the planet.
Laws are just words if you don’t have a body reinforcing them. The US continues to jail its citizens for having the wrong skin colour through ICE too.
unsure where the constitution specifies the FEDERAL government can’t discriminate based on race, the 14th just says the states can’t
ICE jails a fraction of what the US penal system does. If you hate ICE racism then how must people feel about the US justice system that is far far worse.
it’s just ICE I’m familiar with, I despise the prison system in the US but it didn’t feel relevant.
ICE is what is happening right now, you are right.
I was just pointing out this same thing (racial profiling) has always been a part of US policing. The US has destroyed millions of minority and impoverished families with the War on Drugs as just one example.
The Germans are just as bad. I’d say worse, where topics like this are concerned.
That said, freedom of speech is highly overrated.
Nah, speaking at someone in Venezuela, where you can get arrested by mere jokes.