Have you listened to Alice isn’t Dead? It’s in a sort of grey area where it could be interpreted as sci fi or supernatural horror. It’s by the creators of welcome to nightmare but way more suspenseful and creepy with less of the light hearted comedy elements.
Oh man I can’t belive I forgot to include Severance, best show of 2022 in my opinion. I totally agree with you about it ending after season 1, I think they wrapped it up perfectly. I also wish they’d done that with the OA. I do think Severance would have been better if they’d included less “outie” stuff and/or introduced it later - don’t want to spoil this for anyone else reading but I think the moment you see Mark’s face change from fear and devestation to a completely neutral expression (you know the one) would have been a perfect time to start introducing the outside world.