I answered the question already. While PA have been spineless, they did not kill civilians. But you and your ilk then seem to wilfully ignore what Hamas did to civilians. Now answer me, do you and the other guy support Hamas’ October 7 attack? Have other independence movements in other places killed civilians? By supporting Hamas, do you and the other guy don’t support two state solution in essence and do not recognise Israel’s right to exist?
I do not condone the actions of October 7. But I’m not deluding myself into thinking there was another way. How would you tell the Palestinians to struggle for their freedom from occupation and violence? Just in 2018/19, during the Great March of Return, thousands peacefully marched in protest, reminiscent of the civil rights movement or Ghandi’s protests, to demand the displaced Palestinians be allowed to return. They were gunned down in the hundreds.
Are you asking Palestinians to just lay down and die?
Is that a serious question? I’d rather ask you to name a major independence movement that didn’t. War is a bloody affair.
The Irish war of independence did not purposefully kill civilians. They only targeted British military personnel, and the British retaliate by killing Irish civilians, which proved to be to Ireland’s PR advantage for international support for independence (you might mention the IRA in the 1960s to 90s, but that’s a different story right after the establishment of the independent southern part of Ireland, in which the IRA activities had been condemned by the Irish government all throughout). And you mentioned Ghandi’s peace movement for Indian independence, and yet somehow have a doublethink that it wasn’t a major enough.
How would you tell the Palestinians to struggle for their freedom from occupation and violence?
Are you asking Palestinians to just lay down and die?
How about target military personnel only, and not kidnapping civilian hostages, especially foreign nationals with no dog in the race? It’s not that hard to grasp. How is this going to help Palestinian cause? If the Irish freedom fighters killed civilians, that certainly would not have helped their cause for independence.
Answer the question. What did the PA gain by recognizing Israel?
I answered the question already. While PA have been spineless, they did not kill civilians. But you and your ilk then seem to wilfully ignore what Hamas did to civilians. Now answer me, do you and the other guy support Hamas’ October 7 attack? Have other independence movements in other places killed civilians? By supporting Hamas, do you and the other guy don’t support two state solution in essence and do not recognise Israel’s right to exist?
The PA have not made any progress towards Palestinian statehood. If anything, they’ve been complicit in the slow Palestinian genocide.
Is that a serious question? I’d rather ask you to name a major independence movement that didn’t. War is a bloody affair. Here’s the US revolutionaries massacring pacifists, for example..
So did Israel, by the way. To prevent prisoners being taken, Israel killed a non-insignificant number of their own people, soldiers and civilian.
I do not condone the actions of October 7. But I’m not deluding myself into thinking there was another way. How would you tell the Palestinians to struggle for their freedom from occupation and violence? Just in 2018/19, during the Great March of Return, thousands peacefully marched in protest, reminiscent of the civil rights movement or Ghandi’s protests, to demand the displaced Palestinians be allowed to return. They were gunned down in the hundreds.
Are you asking Palestinians to just lay down and die?
If you want a more nuanced take than I can provide, please watch this video by an Israeli, living close to the Gaza strip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pt_1k7nSv1M
The Irish war of independence did not purposefully kill civilians. They only targeted British military personnel, and the British retaliate by killing Irish civilians, which proved to be to Ireland’s PR advantage for international support for independence (you might mention the IRA in the 1960s to 90s, but that’s a different story right after the establishment of the independent southern part of Ireland, in which the IRA activities had been condemned by the Irish government all throughout). And you mentioned Ghandi’s peace movement for Indian independence, and yet somehow have a doublethink that it wasn’t a major enough.
How about target military personnel only, and not kidnapping civilian hostages, especially foreign nationals with no dog in the race? It’s not that hard to grasp. How is this going to help Palestinian cause? If the Irish freedom fighters killed civilians, that certainly would not have helped their cause for independence.